Ruskin's first catalogue with notes containing his plans for the Standard, Reference and Educational series.
This beautiful design is characteristic of mythic symbolism in its purest development: only the student must remember that in taking these dark figures on their red ground as primarily typical of Greek art, we are to consider them only as holding the relation to Greek advanced painting that mediæval illumination does to the work of Giorgione or Bellini. To what extent chromatic power was finally obtained, we have not yet data for determining; but there is no question that throughout the best periods of Greek mural design, the colours were few and grave; and the merit of the composition almost as strictly dependent on the purity of the terminal lines as in the best vases. Neither is there any doubt that the precision of this terminal line is executively the safeguard of noble art in all ages: and in requesting the student to practise the difficult exercises in drawing with the brush, which are placed in the Educational series, my purpose is not to relax the accuracy of his use of the pen, but to bring precision and elasticity into his laying of colour. The actual relations of the two skills require too copious illustration to admit of definition in this introductory course of lectures. The manner of execution, for instance, resulting from the use of the style, or any other incisive or modelling instrument, on wax and clay, and which entirely governs the early system both of Greek and Italian mural painting, is to be considered together with the various functions of incised lines on any solid substance, from Egyptian bas-relief to finished line engraving: similarly, the use of the brush cannot be rightly explained except by reference to the variously adhesive pigments to be laid by it. But, briefly, the pen, or any other instrument of pure delineation, is always best used when with the lightness of the brush; and the brush always best used when, either at its point or edge, it is moving with the precision of the pen. All these line exercises are therefore prepared with the primary view of forming this poised and buoyant accuracy of handling, whatever the instrument held.
The design itself is the best I can find to show the character of early Greek conception of divine power, in alliance with whatever was strong and true in the national temper. The Semele and Dionysus of this noble period represent the fruitful, as distinct from other, powers of the sky and earth; Semele being the sun-heated cloud which dissolves in beneficent rain, distinguished from the wandering and shadowy cloud represented by Hermes. Rising again in light from the earth in which she had been lost, she takes the name of Thyone: signifying that she rises as burnt incense expanding in the air. Compare the various meanings of θύω and θύρσος. Dionysus, under her influence, enters his chariot, and is moved as the life of earth. In these relations, the power of Semele and Dionysus is distinguished from that of Ceres and Triptolemus, as the fruitful sun and rain on the rocks, giving the miracle of juice in the vine, are distinguished from the nourishing strength of the dark soil ploughed for corn.
This is the first of a group of examples, extending from 202 to 220, arranged chiefly with the view of showing the change in Greek conception of deity, which, variously hastened or retarded in different localities, may be thought of as generally taking place between the sixth and fourth centuries B.C. It is one of the most important phenomena in the history of art, and must be studied underall its conditions; but this group of examples from vase-paintings will, at a glance, show the three circumstances in which it principally consists:—
Together with these three great mental changes, an important transition takes place executively, within very narrow limits of time, between the early and late work. The figures of the first period are outlined by fine incision, then filled with black paint laid frankly, and modifying the incised outline, on the red or pale clay of the vase, and the lines of the muscles and drapery are then scratched through to the clay. It is not easy to thicken a line thus incised, and the severity and fineness of style in the drawing are greatly secured by this inability. In the second style, the figures, similarly outlined by incision, are enclosed first with a black line about the eighth of an inch broad, and the external spaces are then easily filled with the same pigment; but this outlining the figures with a broad band, gradually induced carelessness in contour, while also the interior lines of drapery, &c. being now painted, became coarse if too quickly laid, (the incised line, on the contrary, might be hasty and wrong, but was always delicate). Hence, in concurrence with gradual deadening in conception, arose a bluntness in work which eventually destroyed the art.
The best vases, taken for all in all, are however those with light figures on black ground, just after the transition, (the lower Poseidon in 203 is from a very fine one); but decadence rapidly sets in, and the best field for general study will be found in vases with black figures of the most refined epoch, such as 201 and 220.
In the upper figure, the serpent-body represents the force of undulation, but is borrowed from Eastern design. White hair is given generally to old men, but here partly represents foam.
The lower design is pure Greek, and very noble.
These last six examples require fuller illustration than I can give in this catalogue, and are for future service: 220 is very beautiful, from a vase which once belonged to Mr. Rogers (now in the British Museum), and is of great interest, because Aphrodite, who is here a sea-power, and somewhat angry, wears an ægis at first sight like Athena’s, and indeed representing also the strength of storm-cloud, but not of electric and destructive storm; therefore its fringes are not of serpents.